Sunday 19 January 2014

Project narrative (part 1)

Exercise 13 - Deconstruct Martin Shields’ photograph of the two young footballers. What are the denotations and the connotations of this image?

A documentary photograph shows us something, that which we can see when we look at it. But is also tells us something, that which we infer when we look at it.

Denotation is what the photograph shows us – the re-presentation of the original scene.

Connotation is what the photograph tells us.

Denotation – picture shows
1.       Two young boys in football kit walking away from the camera and towards terraced houses
2.       The football kits are different
3.       Regardless of affiliation the boys are clearly friends with arms around each other and are engaged in conversation
4.       The strips are clean
5.       The boys each carry a football
6.       The estate is run down, with broken and boarded-up windows, a number of the houses also have damaged roofs
7.       The land behind the houses has nothing growing
8.       The houses in the middle terrace look like they have completely lot their roofs
9.       The boys are walking cross waste ground at the back of the estate
10.   There are no cars in the picture; there is rubbish on the ground and the estate looks generally run down
11.   The weather is clear with some high clouds

Connotation – my inference
·         From #1 - the boys appear to be aged between 10 and 13 years old
·         From #1 – the looks to be made up of council houses
·         From #1 – the estate could be located in any older industrial town, probably either northern England or northern Ireland or the west of Scotland
·         From #2 – because of the strips the boys play for ‘teams’ and are not just going for a kick-about on the waste ground
·         From #2 - the boys possibly play for different teams, however, they could be on the same team – one team, one goal keeper
·         From #2 – judging by the style of the football strip, the photograph is probably no more than  10 years old
·         From #4 – because of the cleanliness, the boys are going to the game rather than coming home
·         From #4 – the boys look clean and well kempt and probably don’t live in this particular estate
·         From #5 – both football strips look relatively new and with each boy carrying, possibly owning, a football the boys come from families with some money
·         From #6 – the council houses are derelict and without tenants, but possibly have squatters
·         From #7 – possible land contamination because there is nothing growing, there is only two or three small trees and they looks dead
·         From #10 – the weather is warm because the boys are not wearing costs, it is unlikely to rain because the clouds are too high
·         Possible ‘subject’ of the article:
        Housing development and renovation requirements or plans
        Safe and appropriate playground areas for children
        Public transport requirements

No comments:

Post a Comment